I gave this 2 stars, but only for the material. The lining inside of mine was sewn in incorrectly. It looked like they had more "coat" material than lining and ended up pulling both ends in order for it to fit. Because the bottom of the lining is loose and not attached, they were able to do this. But, when I put it on, both bottom front ends looked crooked because of this. Also, there was a big bunch of thread pulled out of coat on the back. If you can get one that is not defective, it's well worth it. The material is beautiful. I had the charcoal in a Small. I am 5"4', 124 lbs and it fit snug which is the way I happen to like it.